Build Quality

The Icom ID-52 feels bigger and has superior build quality. The FT5 has a rougher feel in comparison.

User Interface

Icom has a slicker, more intuitive UI. Yaesu's interface is clunkier and less polished.

Firmware Updates

Icom uses SD cards for firmware updates. Yaesu requires software — Windows only, no Linux or Mac support.

Programming

Both are easy to program. Yaesu's software is simpler whereas Icom's CS-52 is more complex. Neither manufacturer offers Linux software.

Digital Modes

Icom uses D-Star. Yaesu uses C4FM (System Fusion).

Conclusion

Your choice depends on your location (repeater coverage in your area), brand loyalty, and ideally trying both before you buy.

Programming file for the Icom ID52 to work with hotspots.

TX on 434.000 MHz.

Download at: https://bit.ly/3jxTsrs

New Firmware for Xiegu X-6100

Download at Google Drive.

Version 1.1.4 Changes

• FFT peak hold switch
• Fix Gateway WLAN save bug
• RX volume range 0-55
• CW decoder threshold setting
• S-Meter calibration
• ALC level indicator
• Optimized flashing logic

Base Firmware Fixes

• MIC feedback issues
• Booting issues
• ALC algorithm improvements
• SWR algorithm improvements
• Switching power supply sync

ALC Tips

Included with the firmware notes.

The FT817 held the QRP portable crown for 23 years. Now the IC-705 is a serious contender with its colour screen, USB/WiFi/Bluetooth connectivity, and 10W on external DC vs 6W from the FT-818ND.

Comparison

• Price: IC-705 is almost double the price
• Weight: IC-705 is twice the weight of the FT-818ND
• Portability: FT-818ND is better for backpacking (lighter, sleeker)
• Features: IC-705 is better for picnic table operating

Power

At 5-6W USB voice, antenna and location matter a lot. The extra 4W from the IC-705 on external DC can make a difference.

Conclusion

Choose the FT-818ND for portable/backpacking use. Choose the IC-705 if features are your priority.

I bought my RE Himalayan in October 2021 and just did the 300 mile break-in service during the UK winter.

The Struggle

There is a lack of RE dealers near London. Bike Shed Watford went bust. The nearest dealer was a 120 mile round trip. Storm Eunice forced a cancellation.

A colleague suggested Hatfield's Of Crowthorne — only 40 miles away. Got the service done during the storm.

The Result

£30 less than I expected to pay. The Himalayan was a champ in the storm — very sure-footed in the bad weather. If servicing stays this affordable, it's a keeper.